Showing posts with label Introduction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Introduction. Show all posts

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Introduction

The general framework of Kant’s critique appears in his first introduction, by explaining the basic limits of reason and what a critique of its pure form aims to accomplish. It attempts to show where such a priori concepts can be formulated outside of experience. Kant starts by addressing experience itself, and extolling that it can stimulate reason, but not satisfy it, since there are a priori concepts, and no concrete proof of universality. By this denial, Kant asserts pure reason through original concepts that surpass the limits of our experience.

Since he’s mentioned this before he moves onto something a little more important. A question is presented as to which types of judgments can be made through pure reason, so Kant puts forward two types. Analytic judgments, in which the predicate is contained in the subject, are a good deal like Plato’s ideas of the forms, from which all things come, and synthetic, in which the predicate lies outside of the subject, which is seemingly empiricism. In analytic judgments, cognition merely reproduces what we already know, while synthetic judgments aim to understand something outside of the subject, which has a method of explaining experience.

Next Kant talks about this examination of pure reason in terms of a transcendental philosophy useful for the purification of our reason, with a Doctrine of Elements and a Doctrine of Methods. He again mentions sensation and understanding, which, through the former, objects are given to us, and, through the latter, they are thought of.

In the second introduction Kant offers more qualifiers for a priori concepts and their separation from experience. He focuses more strongly on their complete independence from experience, and even goes as far to say that we may know these concepts before experience and allow them to shape experience. These a priori judgments are qualified by two aspects, necessity and universality. If a concept has both of these, then it is an a priori concept originated purely without experience. The issue here presented is the problem with dogmatic assumptions in metaphysics, which qualify things like God without any background or reason, and, when one assumes so much, they cannot be accurately contradicted.

He again mentions analytic and synthetic judgments, calling them “judgments of clarification” and judgments of amplification.” He also emphasizes synthetic judgments, clarifying that all judgments of experience are synthetic, and that the sciences of math and physics that he believes metaphysics should follow are grounded in the same type. This leads to troubles with metaphysics, since it tries to solve problems of pure reason created by itself. Due to these unique troubles, a critique of pure reason is needed for this special science, since pure reason, “contains the principles for cognizing something absolutely a priori.” With his mission statement now out there, a reason defined for his practice, and a few qualifiers regarding how one should picture pure reason, Kant is ready to begin his framework for the basis of human reasoning.